谢双全(James Cheah)'s comment on SUPERMX. All Comments

谢双全(James Cheah)
9 Like · Reply
supermax预计下个星期出业绩,你们心中的业绩是多少?
G L
Don't forget Kossan can continue to raise ASP untill 3rd quarter. Supermax by June will see ASP decline
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Moss Chew
Follow, after @G L became joker in his last post. See this time he will become joker again or not.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
Hahaha GL quite new in this market. supermax is OBM model of course the profit margin higher than kossan and the rest..if asp drop will impact to all gloves not only supermax. what theory if supermax drop and kossan up whilst kossan is not obm...hahaha
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
I am right in the long run. In short run, the market is irrational. Supermax is clearly not worth the current price. It has poor track record in executing the OBM model and was the last in the glove race since 2010. The OBM model only work well during a pandemic. But this model has reached its limits as seen in December's results which was not much stronger than September's. OBM or not, Supermax ASP like Topglove has stretch to a peaking point, meanwhile, less room for ASP spike
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Kossan ASP still much lower, so it will see qoq profit growth all the way to Q3 or even Q4. In Q3, Supermax's profit will fall. Its OBM model is pathetic. Look at the other 3, OEM but much better for the past 10 years than Lousymax.
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Agree that Kossan n Harta raising ASP slower than Topglove n Super and Kossan also doesn’t practice the policy of using max price to sell; in other words , unexpected high profit of Kossan in latest quarter may not mean Super can get something like 30-40% higher than last quarter profit...
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
GL, I did argue the point that OBM model is nothing special n only working well during pandemic but 60-70% of the ppl here don’t understand this point ; then analysis further , how powerful is Supermax brand in the US n Canada market .... Shortage of gloves the main reason that super can sell her gloves with much higher prices to the hospitals n end users ...
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
I concur. The market is a weighing machine in the long term. Currently, most day traders are voting for Supermax. But soon prices will correct and reflect the reality. I also believe OBM does not give a significant advantage. If it did, Hartalega and Topglove will use their own brands too. But they don't. Some also praise Supermax's own distribution model that let it sell higher. But history showed that Supermax is not very good at distributing its own gloves
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Better sell to established distributors like the other glove companies. But Supermax still want to gamble more on ODM by opening large US distribution centre. Imagine how much overhead cost it needs to maintain this just to get a marginal advantage over other glove makers in the US market.
Show more
3 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Before jan of 2020, Supermax top management n sales volume is quite far behind of Kossan n those analysts don’t really analysis Super ... Agree that if OBM model so wonderful , Harta n Topglove would practice this model or mix of 2 models... Brand power ? The western countries are ancestors of branding n Japan n Korea still learning how to operate international brands ...
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
next qr the eps likely will be 50. total eps is around 150. if the pe maintain at 6 share price reflection should be 150x6 = 9. so my tp is RM9. Not a buy sell call. ta and fa is intact.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Remember that Supermax is RM 4 billion more expensive than Kossan. We have to ask how Supermax can earn RM 4 billion more than Kossan. On top of that, Supermax is lousier than Kossan, that is why its pre-pandemic PE is lower, now Supermax PE is higher instead. Kelvin and I are speaking based on facts. Sentiment wise Supermax seems to be better, but TA always lags FA
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
Relax all is up, no need compare just hold
2 Like · 2 years · translate
James Liew
3b.............
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Not even in your dreams
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Retail investors, 60-70% of them r new investors ( less than 3-4 years) n these 12 months trend are the newbies only emphasis in technical analysis n short term goreng ( 3-4 weeks or 2 months )... they don’t bother to learn more about fundamental analysis ... it is normal that don’t understand many points about a company ...
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
1.3 bil is reasonable pat for coming quarter.
2 Like · 2 years · translate
lorance lau
1.2 I m expecting
1 Like · 2 years · translate
James Liew
minimun 2b.......kossan got 1b..supermax sure more than 2b..topglove 3.5b
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Joyce Joan
ok confirm liao
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
1.1-1.3 bil resonate about eps 45-50 for coming quarter. TP RM9 still achievable based on conservative pe 6
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
1.3 bil still doesn't justify why Supermax is more expensive than Kossan by RM 4 billion. Don't forget to factor in Kossan's better track record than Supermax. Supermax is going to build a US plant and distribution centre, which we all know is operationally inefficient.
Show more
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
TP 9 gogogo
3 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
Relax break rm6 first so fast rm9
3 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
calculation based on pe and eps. TP is 9
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
I also forecast Supermax only posted 1.1-1.35 billion quarterly profit ( we don’t know her ASP still up 10% or more )... Supermax quarterly profit of 1.2-1.3 b already 40 times of pre pandemic quarterly profit ( about 27-30 mil).... Kossan n Supermax may have same market cap after June or July ..:)
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
How GL think about the plan of building a USD 500 mil big plant in US , bad news ?
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Tee Yew Ng
Kossan simply 1 b....supermix easyly 2b lar
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
2b dont play la ........ 1.3b very good liao
3 Like · 2 years · translate
Unknown
kossan 1b, supermx 最少2b
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
unless asp increases 100% la...hahaha..1.3b very good alr. dun be greedy...1.3b tp to 9. see my calculation above
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Ng Terrance
要比较的话顺便看看公司总债务对比净现金流
1 Like · 2 years · translate
James Liew
confirm 2b........topglove 3.5b
1 Like · 2 years · translate
wayne wayne
could be 1.4 -1.5b pat but low dividen... how? I
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Unknown
maybe this time give us big surprise
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Unknown
special dividend
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Sean Yee
confirm 20B..haha...haiya, why so many people expect only 2-3B?
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Wai hong Lee
Another stupix appear who the hell expect 20b ? You ah ? Joker
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
20b can when glove is compulsory wear for everyone in the earth la
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Tan David
around 1.3_1.5b...
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Moss Chew
after spending money on expansion still has 1.3-1.5b?
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Want to build a USD500 mil plant in the US, for sure, low dividend policy for 1-2 years..:)
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Besides low dividend policy, the returns from US plant will be poor because it is not cost effective at all. Which means the discounted future value of the RM 2 billion is far lower than the present value.

Supermax has a ROA of 8%. So we will expect Supermax to generate an annual rate of return on that RM 2 billion of 8%. But its US venture suggest it will make far less, possibly only 4%. So for a 10 years horizon, the net present value of the project is negative RM 630 million.
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
we got to see where they park the expenses, most likely won't be in cost of sales. I believe will be in amortisation in current liability. their accountant will know well. last fa their company collected prepayment of 1.4 bil under current assets.
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Nicholas Lim
Don’t waste time with supermax.... shitty dividend even had average 1b last 2Q... so this time even they have 2-3b profit, give u 8cents dividend.... hang urself... lol
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
@nicholas, if you aim for good dividend counters can consider kossan or top glove. this counter more to appreciation of shares price mean ur capital
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Moss Chew
True, my capital gain already 20%. Can run anytime with profit if something is not right.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
yes need to run if something not right
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Meaning, Supermax will make a loss of RM 630 million by opening the US plant. If we stretch the time horizon longer by another decade, the losses will increase further unless it shuts the US plant. Supermax cannot run its glove operation as efficiently as its counterparts, that is why it should trade at a discount
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Innerpeacee
G L, expansion/ investment capitalization will not affect profit loss so pls don’t mislead the readers here, unless SP scrap the factory
Like · 2 years · translate
Yap Teng
prepayment receive from customer will count in next quarter or already count in current quarter?
Like · 2 years · translate
Innerpeacee
Yap Teng, prepaid sitting in bs book so it won’t affect SP profit loss
Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Innerpee r we accountants or investors? As investors, intrinsic value is far more important. RM 2 billion in Kossan is worth much more than RM 2 billion in Supermax 10 years later.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
The fact is, in the next 10 years, Supermax will lose an upwards of RM 630 million or more by opening a US plant which is operationally inefficient. I based this figure on a rate of return of 4% vs its current ROA of 8%. It is destroying value.
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Innerpeacee
Next 10 years... Hmmmm... Fact or projection or merely imagination we will only find out years later before the sentence date
Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Doesn't take long to figure that
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
The management is just a US bootlicker, they have been obsessed with the US market since last decade and failed miserably. Not going to support a management that cannot stop its obsession. Look at Stanley, he bought a condo in US. I think their intentions are clear, they are just obsessed with making a mark in the US market. Amdk
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
lol..bursa market no one can project 10 years, even analysts will project 2 - 3 years...the plan is not a loss.but rather I see i an expansion to the business. the cost can be amortisation to 5 years. if versus the collection of the revenue, can far better manage it.
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
on top of this is a net cash company, the money put in expansion better than spending on sbb.
Like · 2 years · translate
Moss Chew
Can conclude that @GL prefer "safer" counter and doesn't like uncertainty/challenges? I also agree the management should invest the money into expansion for more potential profit whenever there is opportunity (focus on the business but not the share price).
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Bruce Lee
If not mistaken, the next qr will be released on May......
Like · 2 years · translate
谢双全(James Cheah)
Bruce why May?
most banker estimate next week..end of April
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Building a big factory / plant , in accounting method , it is capital expenditure; dont straightaway as cost of sales or expenses, dont affect the quarterly profit directly ... If not mistaken , the plant / asset will be deducted by 10-15% yearly as depreciation / capital allowance ...
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
GL, many don’t understand discounted cash flow n future value of plant after 10 years; in other words, the plant in US will have much higher cost than those glove plants in Malaysia or Thailand , much higher operating cost , maybe per glove cost is double of Malaysia n Thailand plants ; if much higher cost mean operating margin of Super will drop in near future .... So, those said big boss don’t understand the Pro n bad of build a big plant in US?? If US impose import tax of 25- 30% on imported gloves , then maybe no a bad idea but US side hasn’t impose any significant import tax for gloves from Malaysia n Thailand so far..
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Kossan advantage is doesn’t expand production as fierce as Topglove n Super in this pandemic period ; Topglove has practiced share buy back most aggressive then super , share buy back cannot add value to those big manufacturers , just lifting share prices ( like what the big cap US companies doing )... If Kossan able to post 1 billion per quarter, it is much cheaper than Super n Top n Harta ... :)
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
G L
I am not an expert. I just think opening a US plant is not cost effective. Or very not cost effective.
Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Actually I think Kossan even before the pandemic got major expansion plans. The Bidor plant, around 30 billion capacity. After all, glove demand is always on an uptrend, even more so with US universal Healthcare. I think the big 4 is fine as long as they can keep competitors out.
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
G L
I just cannot brain why Supermax is so high. They already make known they don't plan to change their operations but instead double down on the mediocre ODM/OBM business model + US plant. Maybe to Stanley profit not as important as breathing American air and shitting in American soil. Maybe he wants to migrate there lol
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
I and GL think the US500 investment to build a big plant in US, higher chance to be a failure investment ( for this ,analysts in research houses also some support n some disagree ); besides much higher operating cost, there r a lot of rules n regulations in US n EU due to they are advanced counties ..
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
lam kc
kevin, don't act as an expert lah. Simply talk cock here
1 Like · 2 years · translate
lam kc
last time u say glove no hope liao, now also bounce back
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
erm i dunno about glove business

i only care my portfolio

for me which one better profit i go which one tats all wat US plant la / cost efficiency la

macam u all work in glove and live in US wat a funny
statement..... last time said glove is only for small retailers

now said kossan wat wat, supermax wat wat mcm in tat industry long long time haha

The funny statement is those who keep said glove will continue drop one now come and become superb analyst
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
G L
Kevin is right. We agree that Supermax is overvalued, and Kossan is under appreciated. Many analysts agree too.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
ong whey
Kevin Tam still stuck at ocncash 0.68 haha
1 Like · 2 years · translate
lam kc
some people like that one. know a bit act like a tai ko
2 Like · 2 years · translate
liewtz06
I smell hypocrisy in GL. started attacking Supermax ever since switching from Super to Kossan but Super starts shooting up so fast.
2 Like · 2 years · translate
JJason Lim
keep low profile and watch supermax up every week will do, really need low profile
3 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
every ppl comment got their own agenda. from GL perspective he hope that investors will sell supermax and buy kossan. last year rally supermax still the best performance stock in overall. Hence I still trust this counter.
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Wai hong Lee
GL why are you so obsessed about supermx? Go back to your beloved kossan la ... don’t have to show your intelligent comments to guide us to buy or sell ...
Like · 2 years · translate
Moss Chew
Congratz to @GL and @Kevin, kossan up 10%!!
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Don’t be too much conspiracy theory, we r not China versus US... GL n me understand value investing , many here even reading 2-3 books of 冷眼still don’t understand value investment... Super up coz many think it can continue to post more than 1.1 bil profit for next 2-3 quarters n most retail investors like Super, Top n comfort n careplus than boring Harta n Kossan ... Our opinions since 1 months plus ago don’t have any intention for u guys to switch to Kossan... Retail investors prefer to speculate or invest at counters which have gone up faster/ a lot since last year...
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
ong whey
Ya Kevin Tam so good in value investing but how come still stuck at ocncash 0.68 for so many months ya?
Like · 2 years · translate
lam kc
haha. he is god of share mah
Like · 2 years · translate
Yap Teng
kevin before u say glove counter down trend, now glove keep on going up den u terbalik say. 你很矛盾勒, 不好也是你讲, 好也是你讲。 你赢完了咯
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Ong, oceancash will go up to above 70 cents after few months; 68 cents was 30 days ago average cost...:)
Like · 2 years · translate
lam kc
oceancash 0.60 iv
Like · 2 years · translate
ong whey
Waa u said until like con lan firm onccash will go up to above 70 cent, u really thought you are god of shares 啊? laugh die me hahaha
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
U will see , if go up to 70 cents in 4-5 months then how ? Haha
Like · 2 years · translate
ong whey
Since u want to challenge u should said first if no go up to 70 cents in 4-5 months than how? If u really so good in value investing not suppose to stuck and need wait 4-5 months to just break even.Hahaha
Show more
1 Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
Ocncash QR compare glove is almost consider no growth only TA show very weak signal and kevin u go in to said it will reach rm0.70 in near term hallo it is 30% from it current price ler...... if ocncash can reach rm0.70 supermax already rm8 lo, ocncash got wat fundamental dont tell me u go in not for goreng la.... bla bla bla 大户kevin
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
hahaha ocn cash is doing mask. I have reiterated mask business easy to be repricated compare to gloves. alot of new investors don't know this theory.
Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
Glove after covid still using especially during vaccinate..... mask now i selling at rm4.50 dy compare to it height rm100 during march 2020

Glove i now wanna sell cheapest is rm20++ compare to it low rm11

u go to invest mask company and keep saying glove company is goreng stock haha.... wat a funny statement
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Jyh Han Tye
Mask almost dominance by china co la malaysia is only kacang putih in this industry and we have no obvious competitive edge in this industry but glove is different story la..... so 大户的想法只有大户会,我们散户都是sohai
2 Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
kevin马后炮.......哈哈哈哈。。
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Aiya, I said oceancash is undervalued n can go up to 70-75 cents in few months time , is my view ; dont think anyone can just read 1 hour of financial ratio , go to i3investor to read what type of biz then can understand the counter more than 50%.... That guy really small minded , my cost was 68 cents 30 days ago , do I say my cost still 68 cents after 30 days. Good thought still tell the strangers less then feel more comfortable...:)
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
大师Jyh Han Tye, portfolio的50%都是Topglov 和Supermax?
Like · 2 years · translate
Kevin Tam
Warren known too little about ocean but want to show knowledge; oceancash is largest non woven fabric manufacturer in Malaysia n top 3 in south east Asia but she doesn’t produce masks n only supply small quantity of non woven fabric to mask manufacturers... only can tell half to clarify half...:)
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Chee shung Khoo
i agree with jyh. my hq provides ffp2 mask from zhejiang province supplier. medical mask from henan province. during my qatar flight to kl recently from frankfurt, qatar airline uses mask glove hand sanitizer kit from guangdong province. yingke yi liao glove counter also kena goreng up trend recently. jiayou msia top 4 glove counters :)
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Chee shung Khoo
sometimes business decision can b of other agenda. not just cost. because western countries will impose import rules. i guess that decision has to do with creatinf job opportunities there and grab msrket share in that region. my source told me certain manufacturing will move back to western country. how much % i dono. to rely less on asia...also to provide competition a little bit...good weekend everyone :)
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate
Warren B
thats why even good prospect as described by kevin but ocean can't perform well in last few quarters due to the product is not unique and it caused the shares can't move up. ppl would rather buy prlexus due to their mask is specially made to few brands worldwide. the stocks selection from kevin still not so good.
Show more
Like · 2 years · translate