Market Views

Hope for better days ahead after a year of unexpected challenges
Datuk Fad’l Mohamed
CEO
Maybank Investment Bank Bhd
If you were among those (myself included) who approached the start of 2022 with hope bolstered by reopening and recovery, you might have spent most the year wondering how low it could go. Or in the case of interest rates, how high. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in early February came as a jolt that seems to have set the tone for most of the year, with the bears out in full force.
The stockbroking industry had expected weak trading volumes this year, given the macro headwinds and pressure on interest rates and inflation. Average daily trading volume (ADTV) on Bursa Malaysia dipped to RM1.3 billion in July, the weakest month in 2022. There was some cheer after the 15th general election as overall ADTV improved, with volume now at more than RM2.5 billion. The FBM KLCI is on track to close the year circa 6% lower year on year at around the 1,500-point level, with headline earnings contracting by about 5%.
The year 2022 also saw the return of institutional volume, accounting for nearly 50% of the market, while direct retail trading normalised to around 25%, which is close to the pre-Covid-19 pandemic level. Retail investors are looking for safer ground to protect and grow their wealth. After the recent cryptocurrency fallout, investors might have a newfound appreciation for better regulated asset classes.
Buy-the-dip works sometimes, but it is also stressful. Even in a generally bearish year, a sudden change in confidence can still turn markets. November 2022 will go down in history as the time when the Hong Kong stock indices rebounded 20% to 30% in just one month. The question is no longer “will it be up or down”, but “where are the opportunities” when it moves.
A tale of two economies
While I don’t profess to have a crystal ball, my colleagues on the research desk are forecasting a mild global recession with a 40% probability of a US recession over the next 12 months. Global gross domestic product (GDP) is expected to slow to 1.7% in 2023, compared with 2.9% in 2022.
Amid the global gloom, Asean remains a bright spark. While developed markets contended with macro challenges such as surging inflation, sharply rising interest rates and growing recession risks, the impact to Asean economies was more manageable. Expectation is that for the second consecutive year, GDP growth for Asean-5 (excluding Singapore) could be faster at a forecast 4.7% than China’s estimated 4% in 2023.
Economic reopening since 1Q2022 has powered GDP recovery for Malaysia and the broader Asean, with additional impetus coming from sustained and strong growth in trade, still supportive monetary policy and, for Malaysia and Indonesia in particular, high commodity prices. Intra-Asean trade is growing at more than 30%, with the region also benefiting from the supply chain shift owing to China’s strict zero-Covid policy, development of the electric vehicle (EV) industry and the US CHIPS Act. Malaysia along with Indonesia, Vietnam and Singapore are big beneficiaries of the supply chain shifts.
The biggest wildcard is China’s reopening, which could partially offset the US and Europe slowdown. Accelerated reopening will boost the region’s trade, tourism and foreign direct investment, while also pushing up demand for commodities, to the benefit of an energy and commodities exporter like Malaysia.
A new hope
Despite some macro headwinds, we anticipate that equity market earnings ex-gloves will grow at an estimated 17.3% in 2023 on the expiry of Cukai Makmur, improved performance by the banking sector and pick-up in laggard sectors such as transport and aviation.
Other key themes for the year include further government-linked company (GLC) reforms and environmental, social and governance (ESG) developments. The former represents the most tangible and internally driven opportunity to reinvigorate Malaysia’s broad economic dynamism, given GLCs’ outsized weightage in the economy and equity market. As for ESG, significant capital expenditure is needed to meet the public and private sectors’ increasingly ambitious targets in areas such as emissions reduction, EVs and renewable energy.
There is still an abundance of market liquidity as seen from Bursa Malaysia’s 35 public listings this year — the highest since 2018 — which raised a total of RM3.5 billion. Companies with distinct and resilient business models will not be short of investors. Case in point: ITMAX System Bhd, which was listed on the Main Market on Dec 13. The public space networked systems and facilities provider that supports the development of smart cities raised RM342 million, giving it a market capitalisation of RM1.1 billion. Demand from institutional investors was in excess of its market capitalisation and attracted some foreign names among its 13 cornerstone investors, notwithstanding that it was a domestic offering.
For Maybank Investment Bank, 2023 is a special year as we will be celebrating our golden jubilee. Although we have had our fair share of challenges over the past five decades, including economic downturns, financial crises, market meltdowns and the pandemic, we have grown from strength to strength through the continued support of our clients and commitment of our people. Our priority remains supporting our clients through good and bad times.
I may well be proven wrong this time next year (I hope not!), but I am ending 2022 cautiously optimistic that we will see better days ahead.
Respecting economic cycles and market forces
Ng Zhu Hann
CEO
Tradeview Capital
There are good years and there are bad years. When it comes to 2022, it was a very challenging year for investors, both professionals and retail investors alike. What was especially difficult was the impact from the sharp pullback and continuous downward trend through the year. As the saying goes, “Give a monkey enough darts and they’ll beat the market during a bull run.” It is indeed rather easy to outperform when the conditions are favourable, but less so during a bear market. Few can navigate it well and come out unscathed.
Globally, we have witnessed an endless stream of headwinds, including the ongoing Ukraine-Russia war, high inflationary pressures from the surging price of commodities, China’s prolonged “zero-Covid” policy, along with the US Federal Reserve’s hawkish rate hike trajectory and contractionary monetary policies. There were very few bright spots to begin with. While some of these issues were unexpected — but following a strong rally in global markets in the past two years (owing to aggressive expansionary monetary policies to shore up pandemic-hit economies) — was it truly unexpected that 2022 would be a year of correction?
Prudence is an underrated virtue
A broken clock is right twice a day. So perpetual bears are often brushed aside by the investment fraternity. That is, until they end up being right. In this case, very few fall in the category of those who foresaw 2022 to be a year of “deep negative returns”. This ends up happening because, for the capital markets, it is all about chasing returns. Logic and reason have little standing in the pursuit of profits, owing to unfettered risk. The one that delivers the best returns has the loudest voice in the room. This sort of cutthroat environment, coupled with the insatiable greed of men, exacerbates the volatility of the market. It cuts both ways. Thus, if I have chosen one key takeaway for 2022, it reinforces my belief that prudence is the most underrated virtue.
Prudence does not mean sacrificing returns. Prudence does not mean being timid. Prudence means respecting economic cycles and the forces of the markets, which at times move beyond the comprehension of academic theories. Prudence essentially is about risk management and reining in the innate nature of men — greed.
This virtue is severely lacking not only within the circle of investment professionals but also the larger retail investment community as a whole. Case in point: the record-high opening of new Central Depository System (CDS) accounts with Bursa Malaysia in 2021 versus the record-low average daily trading value in 2022. Most investors, specifically new and inexperienced ones, appear mostly when the market is rallying but disappear during a bear market.
Fundamentals are all that matter
After years of cheap credit and easy access to capital, the swift pullback and tightening created a vacuum, which sucked out the oxygen fuelling inflated asset prices across the board. This led to implosions of epic proportion spanning various sectors and asset classes. We have witnessed the meltdown in growth-centric funds and notable exchange-traded funds, tech unicorns, cryptocurrency exchanges and listed companies with no meaningful earnings.
In the private equity and venture capital space, we see funding drying up and companies that have long relied on the fresh capital injection facing going-concern risk, owing to negative cash flow and a lack of options to raise funds or exit altogether. This brings us back to Investment 101, where investing is based on an analysis of the fundamentals of a company. Future prospects will end up being unfulfilled promises without the support of basic healthy fundamentals such as positive cash flow, revenue growth and, most importantly, profitability. These are not complicated metrics to understand and if any investors were to strictly abide by such a thought process, they would have saved themselves a lot of pain. After all, fundamentals are all that matter.
A new chapter for Malaysia
Unlike most who are warning that 2023 will be a year of more pain and potentially of a deep recession, I look towards 2023 with much enthusiasm — in particular for our country. After years of lagging behind regional peers, there is a great opportunity to play catch-up. With the right policies in place under the stewardship of an internationally recognised leader and a likely stable government that may last a full term, next year may be the start of a multiyear recovery for Malaysia. With this fresh start, our country has the potential to drop legacy baggage and walk out of the shadow of the past. Our country badly needs to make up for lost time.
For my 2023 outlook to materialise, the government of the day will need to focus on broadening the tax base, reforming the economic structure to move our economy up the value chain and help develop the backbone of our economy — small and medium enterprises. I understand that all this is easier said than done, as the details lie in the execution and it is a gradual process. If the government has the political will to get started and put the right talents in the right positions while crafting business-friendly policies, we can attract foreign investors to return.
In addition, the new government must not neglect domestic direct investments and re-investments to stem the outflow of funds from the country. Naturally, this will shore up our currency strength and increase our economic pie as a whole. If these concerns can be addressed, investors can rest assured that the stock market at the very least will revert to historical mean.
Optimism defines the future
Although 2022 was a very challenging year for many, including for us at Tradeview Capital, it was also a year of milestones. This year, we obtained our fund management licence from the Securities Commission Malaysia and started operations. It was a long journey to get here and the struggles of building a company from scratch without much resources were very real — especially starting a fund management company during a time when the capital markets were in the doldrums.
As the stock market retraced towards bear market territory, the discipline to be prudent and conviction towards fundamentals were crucial to endure adverse conditions. Above all, our team had to maintain optimism to look beyond the dark clouds. We are glad we managed to navigate all this and deliver positive returns to our clients.
It is with this similar sense of optimism, coupled with the love for this country, that I believe Malaysia and its capital markets still have great potential. The year 2023 is likely to be the start of a new chapter. Let us all look forward to a chapter that is filled with hope, unity and progress for all.
You don’t make an omelette without breaking a few eggs
Datuk Seri Cheah Cheng Hye
Co-Founder
Value Partners Group Ltd
The Chinese government has been successful in transforming China from a poverty-stricken country into a middle-income nation. In fact, by the year 2020, China had caught up with Malaysia in terms of GDP per capita, based on the World Bank’s statistics. Bear in mind that Malaysia has a population of 32 million, whereas China has 1.4 billion people. This was an incredible feat.
Over the last 40 years, over 800 million people in China were lifted out of poverty. This is something that has never been achieved by any country in human history. By the time Xi Jinping took over as president in 2012, China was in a very difficult situation. People like me could see that China was falling into corruption. Since then, Xi has decisively cleaned up the country and made it better governed. He launched a massive anti-corruption campaign, which led to the arrest of hundreds of thousands of people, including many “big fishes”.
From 2015 onwards, Xi also cracked down hard on shadow banking, where people tried to arbitrage between gaps in regulations, which was very dangerous for consumers. In more recent years, he launched the Common Prosperity programme to balance the mix of Chinese policies, which had been excessively pro-business, to become more pro-people.
This process has not been very smooth. It has been quite a rough ride for investors. But you don’t make an omelette without breaking a few eggs. In this particular case, the Chinese government also made its own tactical errors. It was very poor at communicating.
If you look at it carefully, the crackdown on monopolistic businesses such as internet platforms was quite justified. Similar crackdowns had been done in the US, if you look at what happened to Google and Facebook. Then, there was also a crackdown on after-school tutoring, which also made sense. Other countries have been looking at it positively because the effect of the after-school tutoring system is that only the kids of rich people can afford it. Unfortunately, the way China did it was too fast, too clumsy and very poorly communicated to the market. But in the long term, it will all come out okay. In the end, fundamentals do prevail.
Personally, I support Xi’s vision for Common Prosperity. We need to find a more sustainable system that can last much longer for China and the world. China is positioning itself as the key sustainable society going forward. Now, having said that, the US has proceeded to launch increasingly hostile economic sanctions against China. The US became very alarmed by the rise of China, which made China’s position even more difficult. So, China had to respond by putting more emphasis on self-reliance while keeping its doors open to the world.
Then came the Covid-19 pandemic, which was a huge blow to the global economy and China. China responded with its zero-Covid policy. People can look at it both ways. But the point is, the US suffered one million deaths due to Covid-19. So far, China’s casualties are fewer than 8,000 people. Xi has always said he emphasises human lives. Having said that, I think it is time for China to gradually phase out the Covid-19 policy, and I think that’s what it is beginning to do. But the process will take a couple of months before we can see the full opening, possibly in the second quarter of next year.
Definitely, we are seeing light at the end of the tunnel.
China has far too many resource misallocations in the property sector. All the figures suggest that too much housing has been built in China. Xi saw that and he wanted to change it. He wanted to encourage SMEs to use free markets, so he personally launched the third stock exchange in mainland China, the Beijing Stock Exchange. Today, China is by far the busiest stock market in the world in terms of trading volume as well as the number of initial public offerings. The latest figures show that Chinese household wealth has reduced its allocation to property to below 40%, compared with more than 50% in the past. That’s a dramatic reduction.
The Chinese people are redirecting their money from real estate to the capital market. I am excited about it. I believe the Chinese property sector is heading towards a slow-motion crash, which has not created any systematic crisis. But it is still a crash, so a lot of investors lost money. Nevertheless, the system as a whole remains robust and solid. I believe Chinese banks’ exposure to the property market is still manageable because Chinese households are sitting on a lot of savings. Under the Chinese system, mortgages are provided at a very low loan-to-value ratio.
Under Xi, we have seen that his policies have not been very kind to the stock markets. Government officials and businessmen were getting too close, so he tried to reform that. But by doing so, it sometimes creates messages that investors don’t like to hear. Then, geopolitical tensions frightened investors, resulting in hostility toward China in the Western media. China has been consistently put in a negative light. Some of the lockdowns were poorly executed, and they made many people upset.
All these events contributed to the severe underperformance of Chinese stocks. But I would like to think that the worst is over. The most painful reforms have been done. Now, we are looking forward to China’s economic growth in a post-Covid era. Economic growth is now China’s top priority. Right now, Chinese stocks are trading at a price-earnings ratio (PER) of 11 times. I think a more normalised PER would be 14 to 15 times. So, under my scenario, there is room for a rebound. And even if I’m wrong, I think there is only very limited room for further disappointment. Well, that’s unless you think Chinese stocks are totally uninvestable.
Obviously, the last few years have been very rough for China. The rise of China has triggered a negative response from the Western world and Western media. But like it or not, for a country to reform, everyone has to make a little bit of sacrifice. Anyway, I look forward to the future. I remain very hopeful and committed. I think the China story can only get better. Under Xi, China is seeking long-term solutions.
In comparison, the Western countries are looking for a quick fix because their politicians need to get votes. It’s like the “Panadol system”: you take it to cure your headache, but you don’t work too hard to fix the problem. Western systems can create instant gratification, but they are not too interested in creating a better world for 20, 30 years later. They are more interested in knowing, “What can you do for me, right here, right now, today ...?” Just look at how the US prints money to solve its problems instantly. But the Chinese system requires patience and sacrifice for long-term gain. This is a journey that will involve a lot of tears and heartbreaks.” — as told to Liew Jia Teng
The content is a snapshot from Publisher. Refer to the original content for accurate info. Contact us for any changes.
Related Stocks
Comments